Okay, with Varitek, throwing out runners isn't the most improtant stat at all. If you watched the Sox palyoff games and select regular-season games, you'll see how good he is when a close play is at the plate, ex. Burnes when he tripped over Tek's leg and OVER the base, that's one of many.
Now defense is a bigger factor than most may think, the White Sox had it, the Sox had it, the Marlins ahd it, you name it they probably had fantastic pitching along with great defense. Nixon also is in no way a statue, he'll run through a ring-of-fire to get a ball, and has a decent amount of range in RF when he can run at 100%. Manny also, may i remind you led the league in assists last year for some time and wasn't that bad at all.
Ans lastly, Schill admitted in his ESPN inetrview that he rushed back and was injured or not 100% for most of the time he was back. Did you see him when he was on? When he ehld the Yanks to under 3 runs twice?