The only thing about guys who strike out is they tend to have no consistency with their batting average. They might hit .301 one year and then .260 the next. Supposedly, guys who K a lot also age less gracefully than the guys that consistently make good contact. That said, I would rather have a guy hit .260 with plus power, and RBI potential, than a guy like crisp who best case scenario hits .260 with virtually zero potential for power or RBI who might make contact a little better. I would way rather see Wily Mo with the bases loaded, because he has a good chance of putting one over the wall for four runs and if there is 1 out, I'm not worried about Pena ending the game with one swing grounding into a DP. With Coco, I am. Strike outs have their uses. Besides, at least in limited time last year he hit .301 and showed good power. Sure he looked bad sometimes, but he is producing.
Personally, I'm not worried about how Wily Mo will age because I don't think he will still be here past his prime. I think he is capable of 30+ home runs, a good amount of RBI, and could protect anyone who bats in front of him because he always is a threat to go deep. Always.
I also don't care what his average is. If he plays enough, he is a presence, its just where do you play him. Thats my problem with Wily Mo, he doesn't have a position because he is terrible every where. If I were Theo, I would think about maybe packaging wily with a Hansen or a Bard (at the deadline) and see if I couldn't reel in a quality reliever from someone out of the race. IF the Twins are out of it, Juan Rincon could be available. If the Rockies decide to have a fire sale, Fuentes could be out there. There are other guys too, but thats what I see wily mo being used for. Right now he has way more trade value than coco crisp does. He is 25, lots of hitting potential, he could DH for the twins which would be his best option.
He isn't a bad player, but because of Papi, he doesn't really have a role on the team and people think he is worse less than he is because in order to get him at bats, we have to watch him fumble around in the field and see the strike outs and the impatience at the plate. It makes people wanna strangle him. He has a lot of value to the right team... like the twins. I hope we can find something to put this division away out on the trade market, and wily mo could help us get that piece.
Kilo, you're the man.