But there were hints of this non-performance last year. I'll admit, I thought they were best available too, and I was optimistic about what they could do for the team. But, just because they fit the "best available" moniker, it doesn't mean the FO didn't seriously overvalue these players, and they did do that. They were hot for these players years ago, and despite some hint of potential struggle (the injury protection clause for Drew, Lugo sucking the 2nd half of 2006), they inked them to big $$ long-term deals with no reported competition in the market.
I think, and hindsight is helping here - although so is a shift of attitude, they need to do a much better job of risk management. They got the best players available, but the worst case scenario happened, and now they stuck with them. Hopefully, they can turn it around. However, I'm starting to think prudence would dictate they avoid the big/long contract unless its for elite players, and, while these guys have talent, I think they are just short of elite (maybe Drew has elite talent, or did at some point, but he looks like a shell of the player he was in Atlanta).