The whole season for the Jays surprises me. I thought that this year would be the year that all 5 teams in the division were in a dogfight for first. I honestly expected the season to end with no more than three or four games separating all of the teams.
When the roster includes Buerhle, Dickey, Johnson, Reyes, Encarnacion, Bautista....well, it just seemed like a great team. Dickey coming down a bit I could understand, his Cy Young season seemed like a once-in-a-career season at best and a bizarre fluke at worst, seeing as he's a knuckleballer. But no way did I think they would be this bad.