Taveras 34 SB, 11 CS, that means he got caught 32 percent of the time he tried. Not good to give away outs. He also had a pathetic .324 OB% for a lead off hitter. Youkilis had a .364. Taveras had a .666 OPS in a HITTERS park. That = bad.
You talked about his defense. Which he is pretty good at. But it doesn't justify his bat. I'd bat him 9th in the order and just let him work his glove out. However I think Adam Stern, someone we don't have to give up a player for would do about the same. Higher average or higher on base. I believe ON BASE percentage means he is ON BASE more, giving him MORE opportunities to score. Oh yea, I'm right. SB is overrated too, just to let you know. Otherwise Jose Reyes should be a top 5 SS in the game, whereas he is one of the worst.
As someone already posted, Payton was not happy with a back up roll (don't know whom he thinks he should have started in front of?). But back in a starting role his relationship will be fine and is a fine stop gap player. You said he is a bench/platoon guy. Again whom do you think he should have started in front of? Nixon, Damon or Ramirez? Roberts is a fine STOP GAP CFer. WILL COME CHEAP. They would trade him for Wells, but again if you read anything that goes along with trades lately, the Padres want to package Roberts with Woody Williams. I wouldn't do that.
Me grow up? You haven't proven a thing besides crying and bitching about Payton or Roberts. What do you want? Jim Edmonds or Andruw Jones to fall in your lap?
Sorry for having a life. I post regularly at http://www.forums.netsports.com. Go there if you want to see "credibility" if you don't think I haven't shown things in the past.
Next time you guys want to talk about player evaluation, don't bring a knife to a gun fight, suckas.