How many #2 hitters have we had the last 4 years?? Mark Bellhorn, Bill Mueller, Orlando Cabrera, Mark Loretta, Todd Walker, Edgar Renteria.......its not going to mess with the team chemistry as long as that player can get on base for Ortiz and Manny. If you added Julio Lugo I would suggest having him leadoff and having Coco Crisp batting 2nd (where he has had most success in his career).
1. Julio Lugo
2. Coco Crisp
3. David Ortiz
4. Manny Ramirez
5. Trot Nixon
6. Jason Varitek
7. Mike Lowell
8. Kevin Youkilis
9. Alex Gonzalez
.....speed, power, OBP.....that lineup is just fine and the Red Sox could add some pitching. I'm not saying Julio Lugo is the guy we would get if ANY deal were to occur (we could get someone better) but again....we can't critique any deals until they happen