This thread was not meant to be about Lugo as much as it was about the decisions of the front office at this position over the last three years.
If you think you can compare Lugo to Pedroia, good luck and I hope your right, because were stuck with Lugo for 4 years.
But the fact is Pedroia has turned it around and Lugo hasn't. Pedroia knew he had to earn his place, where Lugo has 4 years at 36 million.
Since Nomar was traded, there has been a revolving door at shortstop with no success.
Refusing to pay OCab after '04 may be the biggest regret (.328 avg, 74 hits, 29 rbi, 40 runs scored, 3 hr)
Signing Renteria may be the biggest blunder, but he's an all-star again (.326 avg, 74 hits, 29 rbi 41 runs scored, 8 hr).
Letting Gonzalez and his glove go may be the biggest puzzle considering how the improved pitching would benefit from a better defensive shortstop, plus he's hitting well (.272 avg, 56 hits, 26 rbi, 32 runs scored, 11 hr).
And trading Hanley Ramirez in the deal for Beckett, which seems fair now, but can only be adequately judged years from now. This guy was Theo's "untouchable", until his Halloween exile in '05. Now he is an all-star (.309 avg, 72 hits, 51 runs scored, 8 hr).
So we are left with Julio Lugo, long coveted by the organization, who finsihed the last 49 games with LA last year hitting .219, and was rewarded with 36 million dollars (.224 avg, 48 hits, 33 rbi, 27 runs scored, 3 hr).
Sure he's the rbi leader among shortstops (barely), but he isn't scoring runs and getting on base and shows an erractic arm defensively.
If you guys want to make quick sarcastic comments, then fine, I don't pretend to know it all.
It is great to see Pedroia showing signs of making a future for himself at second (which has been a revolving door also for a couple of seasons), but the decisions at shortstop have been reactionary, miscalculated and costly.