Red Sox Video
He is not Trevor Rogers, of course, but there are some reasons why David Peterson appears to me as the clear-cut best left-handed option for the Boston Red Sox to pursue in free agency (should they choose to double down on their southpaw-heavy rotation).
He once again demonstrated the ability to generate ground balls and avoid hard contact in 2026, especially after he arrived in Chicago, where he managed to make a major turnaround after leaving the New York Mets. Peterson won't turn 32 until next September and, although he has sometimes gone through injuries and periods of inconsistency, he has always bounced back.
He appears among the only 15 left-handed starting pitchers who have accumulated at least 400 innings pitched over the last three seasons, which should be music to the Red Sox's ears after all the injuries they dealt with this past season. But he's not just an innings-eater; he also ranks as the pitcher with the third-highest GB/FB rate (2.01) in that time, in addition to recording the fourth-best soft contact (14.1%) and HR/9 (0.67) rates.
Another point that makes me lean toward thinking of Peterson as a good target is that he will not be an expensive pitcher. Most outlets peg his value around $12 million annually, so a one-year offer would make sense if the Red Sox decide to take a chance.
So, what are his flaws? First of all, his control problems stand out and, among the of left-handed pitchers above, Peterson has recorded the highest walk rate (9.4 BB%). However, it is fair to point out that, after moving from the New York Mets to the Chicago Cubs in late June, many of his control problems were improved upon.
Better control led Peterson to have more confidence attacking hitters and, at the same time, gaining advantages over his opponents, to the point that his percentage of plate appearances with two strikes rose from 45.1% to 52% when he moved from the Mets to the Cubs. Given that Peterson was consistent in two-strike counts throughout the year, with an 18.49 K/9 rate against 319 opponents pitching for New York and 15.90 in Chicago, that was a crucial improvement.
Although his HR/FB rate jumped from 9.8% to 13.6% after the trade, he compensated with more strikeouts and fewer walks. And a lot of those home runs were the result of unfavorable Wrigley Field conditions, rather than any actual decline in his performance.
In fact, the dimensions of Fenway Park would have reduced the home runs Peterson allowed in 2026 from 15 to just eight, a difference that reinforces the value he could bring to the Red Sox's rotation.
Want to play the role of Red Sox general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Red Sox roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now