This is NOT all that complicated.
D.
Iggy is an incredibly talented SS, with God given physical speed and agility that few SS & athletes have. He has also obviously worked incredibly hard in honing these skills. Not many come close to being able to match his abilities to make spectacular defensive plays.
Bogie has CLEARLY worked hard at becoming a very good MLB SS! He makes most of the plays Iggie makes. He's better than most MLB SS, and he's getting better every year.
O
Bogie is CLEARLY the superior offensive player!
HR's Bogie 20, Iggie 5 > That's 15 bombs that likely helped the Sox win that day. 15 games where he had a significant impact on helping his team win. ( yeh yeh yeh..., I get that there are games where he had multiple HR's)
RBI's: Bogie will end the season with close to 100. Iggie 50. That's +50 runs over the season (duh )
50 times Bogie gives us a significantly better chance of winning.
Runs scored: Bogie 65, Iggie 43, yeh, getting on base matters
OPS .869 vs .699
* Bottom line, I take Bogie's VERY SOLID D, and his CLEARLY SUPERIOR bat every day of the week, and never give it a second thought.
I don't need WAR to figure this out. I don't need WAR to tell me that I THINK Bogie is the no-brainer choice if I'm an MLB GM.
Now, having said all this, my original OP was simply to acknowledge a great year by Bogie. I probably shouldn't have mentioned Iggy. I like him very much, and fully acknowledge that he is a one of a kind SS. I still take Bogie without a second thought, so I guess in my mind Bogie is a far superior SS option when factoring in Offense (The other 1/2 of the player evaluation equation).