I hear what the numbers state, but at the same time I've also seen (here?) that there are studies that say that your "best" hitter should be hitting 1st, 3rd, or 4th. That seems to confirm what I've learned, that if someone wants to prove something there will be studies there to confirm it.
My personal opinion FWIW and not confirmed by any studies is that a team should have it's best OBP hitter batting first, the hitter with the best OPS 3rd, and the best HR hitter batting 4th. Which leaves the problem of what to do when one hitter qualifies for two - or even three - of those spots?
And isn't that where we are with Mookie?