Well said, but I will add that the argument that "He was never given a real chance" implies he deserved one, and that he never got one. I disagree on both fronts.
Besides, he actually got a pretty long look when he was the starter for about a half a year. He hit decently that year (good for a catcher), but never showed growth on defense or "staff-handling." He started the next season, and when they saw no further growth on defense, he was quickly (and rightfully) replaced- pretty much for good as a catcher.
He got a pretty good look last year, when Vaz got hurt, and again did not distinguish himself.
How many prospects, who never did great in the minors, sticks around so long with much of it on the ML roster?
I'm okay with what happened, but I get worked up when people say, "He never got a chance!"
IMO, he got more chances (including looks at other positions), more time and more looks than anyone with his record deserved.
I can name dozens of ex-Sox prospects who had great minor league careers and got 1/10th the chances Swihart got. Some, who went elsewhere proved they never belonged, but even if Swihart goes on to prove he does belong, I will still believe we gave him more opportunities than he deserved.