My favorite player was JBJ, and he certainly wasn't the best player, but I love great defense, especially up the middle. (I used to play 2B then CF and pitcher later in softball.) I think I know why I like some players, and I guess I was wrong for assuming most people know why they like one player and not another.
I really was not trying to be critical.
I do think that it kinda sucks when your favorite player leaves, but letting Beni and JBJ go had plenty of merit.