To be honest the amount of player movement and resulting experimentation being contemplated is one of the things that makes me seriously doubt that the Sox are going to be able to make much progress toward the post season this year even with the added WC. It is not the only issue but it is one of them.
We have Youk who if the Sox had their druthers would have just started this season and had as close to a typical Youk type of good season as possible. Instead he ends up validating our concerns about what might go wrong with him this year about as completely as possible leaving the Sox with another heavy contract player and really not many options as far as what to do with him.
In truth I think the Sox are forced to give Youk playing time. While it does showcase him, I really don't think that is what they want to do with Youk this year. The Sox would really like Youk to makes his way back because if he does, the Sox know what they have in Youk. As well as WMB has played and as much as I would maybe prefer that Youk just disappear in some way that gets the Sox something in return in truth, the Sox really don't know what they have in WMB. Might he turn into a pumpkin via his lack of experience at the ML level? Might pitchers learn how to pitch to him and take the edge off of how sharply he has performed at the plate so far? Yes on both counts. Neither possibility diminishes WMB's value long term but if Youk were gone and WMB turned into a pumpkin at that point, all you have to do is look at how the Sox look with Youk doing poorly to see how they would look with WMB doing poorly.
They designed this year's roster with Youk succeeding in mind possibly even considering exercising the team option on him for next year if he really excelled. As much as I don't like it I don't think the Sox end up sellers on Youk unless they end up sellers with a capital S this year. So in my view the Sox end up having to give Youk time at 3rd mainly because they really can't afford to give up on the Youk that they were hoping to get this year.
Then we will soon be confronted with the dice experiment. Bard will soon eat through the innings that the Sox have probably allotted to the Bard to the rotation experiment and will likely have dice up here with the Sox trying to figure out if he can pitch well enough to move Bard back to the pen for the balance of the season. There is the Cook experiment sort of still born at the moment but still hanging out there waiting to be revisited.
There is the fact that while Salty has these moments of glory there is little to suggest that they are more than that and it is hard not to want to get the Lavs experiment going because the Sox also know what they have with Salty at this point. The difference between Youk and Salty is that while if Youk gets going the Sox will want what they can get from Youk, if Salty gets going you are still stuck with little that will help this team succeed. While Salty is strong and capable of going deep this year even when he is giving us the best he has to offer at the plate he is still surrounding his successful at bats with tons of punch outs to pitchers that are not what you would consider Cy Young candidates or even top of some team rotation candidates.
While we would desperately like to pencil CC in for a season similar to a TB season we have nothing to go on that says there is more than a 50-50 chance of that happening. Add to that now the fact that Ells has suffered a large joint injury. As such, a degree of uncertainty exists with regard to what we might expect from Ells when he gets back. If you don't think that is so, tell me we have the player we thought we would have in Agons....who has turned into Wade Boggs in a larger suit size.
And then there is the one thing that has been pretty reliable so far this season. It has gotten to the point where you could pretty much rely on 1,2, 3 in the rotation stinking up the joint.
While I love seeing us finally win a few games and I love seeing some of the Pawtucket gang really having a major impact after I wake up from my victory induced drunken stupor I am stuck with the same set of problems that I had at the start of the evening.