I think that if they want to keep all these bats in the lineup at the same time they need to find a different position for WMB who is a much more athletic player than AGons. Agons in RF is looking less like risk and much more like Russian Roulette especially after tonight.
AGons is not out there for his defense. He is out there because they want to keep his bat, Ortiz, Youk and WMB in the lineup at the same time. Agons is not my favorite player for a number of reasons. However we are asking him to choose between the risk of injury and making routine plays. That is a lousy position for the player and really an unfair position. We should not kid ourselves that we are doing less. We are asking him to choose between risking injury and making routine plays.
Really when you look at AGons production in last few weeks either they should find another position for WMB if they are adamant about keeping all these bats in the lineup at once or they should "rest" Agons a bit more. He is doing very little with the bat at this point to justify the risk they are taking with him in RF. That HR he hit a few days ago was the consummate Fenway homer, an out everywhere else. That RBI double he got tonight was an embarrassment for both Coke the pitcher and the Tigers Right Fielder. It should not have happened. Agons is not hitting at present. Rest him a few days. He might actually come back and hit again.
We can live without watching AGons swing aimlessly for a few days. We cannot live without Ortiz, Youk and WMB for their power and we cannot live without Nava for his overall playing ability at this point. Either find another position for WMB or rest AGons for a few days and see where we are then.
While they are doing that, work WMB out at another position and see what they have.