Come on now, it's a legitimate possibility. HanRam was obviously signed as an IFA by the Sox, and the trade for Beckett and Lowell was made during that 3 month span where Theo had left. Theo has had a huge love affair for Hanley in the past, as noted when he tried to reacquire him in the 2008 offseason
This was in 2008, when it didn't make sense for the Marlins. Now, it's being reported that they may trade him.
So why is it such an outrageous notion that Theo would still be attempting to acquire him? Because he's having a tough season? Maybe a change of scenery is what he needs.
We all know that Youkilis is our future DH, whether that's next year or in 3 years, who knows, but someone is going to have to play 3B. Why not put Hanley at SS until Ortiz leaves, then stick Youk at DH, HanRam at 3B, and play Iggy at SS. If the deal for Hanley takes Iggy, you've got 2-3 years to develop Xander Boegarts, who projects to be a SS with a high offensive ceiling.
The deal makes sense, and with Theo's history of attempting to reacquire HanRam, along with his lovefest for him (and his history of acquiring guys he has a lovefest for), all point to this being a real possibility. So don't just dismiss it because we've heard it before. If we did that with every trade rumor, we wouldn't have the AL MVP at first base.