Yeah I'm an optimistic fan because I saw how well this team played last year with a horrible back end of the rotation, so I know they're better than a 90-72 record.
I was just reacting to a post that said all of this was to be expected, etc, because its really not to be expected. I even said "If you project Beckett to post a 3.8-4.2 ERA, that's reasonable (which is what you've since projected, so that's reasonable)" but even that would have been 7 IP, 3 ER (which translates to a 3.86 ERA). Beckett's outing today was beyond atrocious so the fact that people are saying it wasn't surprising is crazy, that's all.
And if anything, I would call this year the last chance for guys like Youkilis and Ortiz to win a WS with this team. Next year will be the year where they are starting to rebuild by using guys like Iglesias, Lavarnway, Middlebrooks, etc.