That's the thing, evil.
Youkilis is never healthy. Nobody is arguing that he's no longer talented. The argument is that he is not consistently healthy. He has had an ENTIRE offseason to get healthy, and he came back and was on the DL within a month. He's clearly not right at the moment, either.
Even when he was "healthy" at the start of the season, he was terrible, awful. During ST, he was getting beat badly. He's missed 127 games since 2010. That's 32.9% of the past 3 seasons!!! And when he actually DOES play, he's not even very good because he's constantly trying to play through injuries.
He has no value man. He's got no value.
Going back to last July, that's 71 games, 291 PA where he has OPS'd below .650.
He had an ENTIRE OFFSEASON to get healthy. He comes back, on the DL within a month.
You tell me. Why the hell would any team want to trade for that?