1)Start Lowrie. I like Scutaro, and everything he provides, but you play the hot bat. Lowrie will get injured, and Scutaro will have his shot again, but for now, playing a lessor player to boost his confidence just isn't the right move.
2) Stop shifting the lineup. Find something that works and try to keep guys in the same place. If you have to move guys in and out of spots, do what you have to do. Keep players in spots that work-- ie Pedroia 2, Agon 3, Youk 4. Throwing everyone around isn't helping the offense. Crawford at 1 isn't working, he just doesn't like hitting there.
3) Let Dice-k do whatever the hell he wants. Its been 4 years, and he still isn't listening, so let him pitch how he wants to pitch. If that doesn't work, phantom DL him.
4) Stay the course with Lackey and Buchholz. Lackey pitched to career numbers in the second half of the year in 2010 after he got used to Boston, he will figure it out. Buchholz is too good for this, maybe he was distracted by contract negotiations.
5) Have a serious discussion with the pitching staff about Saltamacchia. Figure out if he is part of the problem. In opportunities starting, Varitek's pitcher has been 2/2 on QS, and Salty has been 1/9. If we need an offensive blackhole at catcher, so be it, but if our catcher is part of the pitching problem, something needs to be done. Personally, I don't know enough to make this claim about Salty, but Tito is in a position to figure it out.