As a Red Sox, Ortiz's slash line is .292/.390/.572/.962. 9 All-star games, 5 Silver Sluggers (not including his inevitable 2013 win), five top 5 MVP finishes, two World Series rings, and a member of the 50 home run club. He has been the face of the franchise, he's played 11 years here so far, won a Roberto Clemente award, and he ain't done yet.
Unless something happens to his reputation, he should be a lock.