Also, his career OPS is 100+ points lower away from Coors.
It'd be dumb to trade the farm, to bring back a contract that runs for 8 more years for a guy who has spent his career in Colorado.
For the Red Sox urposes, it's not $16M per. It's $19.5 from 2014-2020. 2011 and 12 are irrelevant to the Sox and this discussion.
It's too much money for a SS when any $ should go towards pitching, but not on 8 year contracts.
Trumbo for Ells/Barnes/Brentz is a horrible trade. If you're trying to get a #1 starter, sure. 1b is one of the easiest positions to fill.
Don't want to trade for pitchers? GioGonzalez looked pretty good this year.
Waiting on FA's is a horrible business model because you may have to wait a few years until a great pitcher shows up.
He's just not very good anymore. An injury prone guy who hits under .240 with diminishing power? That doesn't sound fun to me. There are way better options out there. It also doesn't help that he's a prima donna who loves drama. When you're such a problem that even Manny had to tell him to chill out, you're probably not the best guy to be around.