Youkilis isn't getting in. Ortiz isn't getting in mostly because of the PED issue and his DH effect. Had he not had the PED cloud, he'd be a borderline case because his offense is and was THAT good. The guys who put up big counting stats make it in based on what they do after 35. The guys who dominated a position for a decade will get in, even if they fade late in their career. Also, winning goes a long way as does being the leader on the team. Pedroia gets in assuming no catastrophic injury. Lester isn't even close mostly because he's basically wasted 2 yrs of his prime plus lost some yrs of his prime with cancer. He's just not that dominant. You know who is on pace to get in? Papelbon. He's already had 7 consecutive seasons of 30+ saves and he is only 32 and in the midst of a vintage yr. If he keeps this up for another 3 yrs or so, he'll end up as one of the best of all time (nowhere close to the best, btw)