Getting back onto the topic, I do not think it is time to fire Theo. He has brought consistency to the team that was so horribly consistent in the past that they couldnt get out of the way of themselves. Firing him after one year that appears to be headed downward is something I'd expect George to do, not Henry.
At the same tiem, Theo does need to be held accountable for this season and he needs to lose the guise of this all-knowingly great GM guy. He is a guy who fell into a great situation in Boston and made some low risk moves that paid off huge. With those guys added to a solid infrastructure already in place, the sox were a force in 2004. But it all came back to pitching. In 2004, he could have bought up Paps, but he didnt need to. He had 5 starters who all went to the bump nearly every time and were all guys who could either win a game outright or keep you in the game until Papi decided to win it. That saved innings on the pen and guys like Leskanic and Williamson ended up being used very seldom and were strong and fresh for the playoffs. Add to that the fact that Embree and Timlin were rested and Foulke was lights out and the sox had a pitcher on the mound in every single inning of the months of august, september and October that could get the job done.
Fast forward to this year where the majority of the sox moves were made on defense and offense with Theo adding one young stud and a bunch of questionable pieces to the staff. On paper, at the beginning of the year, Theo had done his job, or so it seemed. He knew Wells was coming off knee problems. He knew Clement was a guy who couldn't be trusted. He knew that Schilling was a ?? at best. He knew that he had no idea what to expect from Beckett. Those very facts right there should have been enough to hang onto Arroyo. Instead, he dealt him away for an OFer, who is very serviceable for this yr, but he is absolutely not what the sox needed. If Arroyo were on this team, then you have 3 starters who can at least give you a QS 60% of the time and then you have Lester, who won't have as much pressure on him. Theo also had the chance to pick up Lidle, who has been a solid pitcher in the AL before and is an innings eater. Instead he watched them send Lidle to the hated rivals for peanuts as a throw in, ignoring the fact that the guy had success in the MLB before and he is a guy who only lasted less than 5 innings once this yr. He averaged over 6IP per game, and he would be a welcome addition to a depleted staff. Instead he did nothing and essentially doomed this team. I won't say he should be fired, but he should now have a little tarnish on that impeccable image.