I thought this was a bad trade from day 1. Why? Wily Mo has a lot of talent but he hasnt proven he can be an effective day to day player. This yr, once again, a small sample size, he may be showing signs of breaking out. His MO is loads of power but easy to figure out and over the long haul, that will translate into tons of K's, lots of HRs, and a low BA. His BA will fall as the league learns him a little bit.
Either way, the deal of arroyo was one that should have irked a lot of sox fans. You deal away a guy who doesnt back down against anyone and he was the most consistent starter on the sox last yr. Take a look at his QS%. His was top 5 in the AL last yr and led the red sox team. He was never spectacular, but he'd go 6 and give up 3 like it was easy. Also, the guy LOVED Boston. He signed for well under market value to stay in the city he loved, and as it turns out, after he signs that deal, he never puts on the Boston uniform again.
Now, for those of you who say that Wily Mo is better, think about the possibilities. Everyone knew that Oswalt was available for Andruw Jones. It was known, it was easy, it was there. The Braves wanted to get younger in both the pen and in the rotation. They wanted Crisp, Lester, and Hansen. Crisp has become a major bust and was readily expendable even if Wily Mo wasnt there (Kapler is better than Crisp these days). Hansen is closing in on bust status as his stuff is good, but it is flat and hitters love it, so he would have been easy to part with. The sox refused to part with Lester. It had nothing to do with Lester being projected as a fine MLB starter one day or anything, it had everything to do with the fact that it still didnt address the sox main need, and that was 2 more spots in the rotation. Assuming the sox never make the Wily Mo deal, then Arroyo is the 3, Lester the 4, and Wells the 5. If Arroyo was not dealt, I have no doubt in my mind that Oswalt is suiting up in the Boston locker room.
In essence, this trade screwed the sox out of a back of the rotation starter who has proven he can play in Boston. It showed how disloyal the FO is and hence will make any other resigning nearly impossible unless the sox go market value or higher. And, it screwed the sox out of obtaining one of the best young PROVEN aces in the game. Tell me how having Wily Mo vs having a few more wins and having Schill, Oswalt, Beckett, Arroyo, Wells coming at you 1-5. That would have been a beast to overcome in a playoff series and in the chase for the east. Theo blew it, and this trade was the totality of it all.