I disagree with needing to have max production out of the typical offensive positions. The sox have 2 grade A hammers in their lineup. You dont need another one. What you need is to make the rest of the O strong enough to make it impossible to get around the hammers, to continually be on base, and to drive in runs throughout the lineup. Having a lopsided lineup will not work pitchers, which will keep them fresh when they have to face the hammers. The sox were the best in 04 at pitches per plate appearance. That forced starters out of games earlier and they feasted on the weak MR. It also caused the sox to see tired starters, which made for easier scoring against even the best in the game. That doesnt happen if you have 3 1.000+OPS guys and a bunch of scrubs. If you have Ortiz and Manny plus 7 other guys with a .800OPS, the lineup will be deadly. No dead weight, just production all around and the lineup will do what it did 2 yrs ago. If you want to stratify the offense based on which positions need O, then you will create an offense even more reliant on the middle of the order. The 2004 team was reliant on papi and manny, but they could get the job done around them too. Last yrs team couldnt. That was the difference. Make the moves to improve the OPS of 1-9 and the teams O will become legendary again.