he has been done for awhile? Did anyone see his composites in Houston? NL or no, they were impressive. And as for letting Pettitte walk, it was obviously a poor decision and one very akin to Damon's treatment in Boston. The yankees were fresh off 2003 where our offense failed us. Steiny was in full swing and decides to get Sheff and ARod while passing on retaining one of the most reliable pitchers in yankee history. Pettitte was put off by the lack of respect and signed with Houston. What people fail to realize is the yankees offered more yrs and more money than Houston did. Funniest thing of all, though, is the sox trumped everyone. If I remember correctly, the yankees offered 4yrs 52, while the sox were in the 5 yr 60+ range. He was offered a significant contract, but Steinny was too busy acquiring the Kevin Brown's and Javy Vazquez's of the world to notice that he had a great yankee pitcher walking right out from under him.
Pettitte is no savior and never was a savior. He is a solid pitcher who will give consistent, unspectacular performances throughout the season and will elevate his game a little in the playoffs. He wont K 15 batters and sure as hell wont pitch any perfect games. But he very quietly wins a lot of games and posts quality starts.
Last yr he put up 20QS's in an off yr. Higher than anyone in the NYY-BOS battle aside from Mussina who had 23. In 2005 he led the majors in QS with 27. 2004 he was hurt, but in 2003, he had 20 again. For many and for me too, QS is not the best indicator of how good a pitcher is, but it is a good indicator for how they will fit into your team. If you have a solid bullpen and a great lineup, a QS will lead to a lot of wins. If your pen and lineup suck, a QS is meaningless. He is not spectacular. Not by a long shot. But when you put up QS's with NY's lineup and NY's bullpen you are going to win a fair share of games.