good thread.
My 2 cents, completely aside from my allegiance.
Grace periods are ********. You win a championship then f*** up the team afterwards, you should be fired. The sox moves were justified at the time, but eventually results are required as is a direction. After 2004, the sox had one hell of a farm and one hell of a team. The team dissolved, which in hindsight looks pretty good. They had a very bright outlook in terms of farm and then made some deals that are bearing fruit for their competitors. The direction of the sox after 2004 was, we fired all cannons and won it all, now we need to reload. After 2005 it was, lets deal away our prospects for players who are certainly no sure thing. After 2006 it was spend a ton yet leave the least expensive area of the team unguarded.
If the sox dont make the playoffs this yr, then analysis is needed. If the moves that have Theo's fingerprints on them were to blame (Matsuzaka, Bullpen, Papelbon moved to the pen, etc.) then theo should get shitcanned. Then again, the way things have gone since the sox won look pretty good