So pitchers who finally click dont ever lose their mechanics again? So a pitcher isnt allowed to have a career yr and then go back to previous? Again, I am not saying he will be anything but solid this yr, but sitting here and saying he is a lock to be a top 3 CY candidate again is far from assured.
Manny's swing always looks good. It is hardly ever his mechanics that is his problem. As always, his problems have been health (more recently anyway) and his mentality. Throw in advanced age and he is far from a sure thing.
MHOF, you are trying to push some things onto the yankees to make yourself feel better when this really is a universal issue. Both teams have the potential for big time offenses. Both teams rely on older players as their core offense and the possibility of injury or decline is real. Both teams have a top heavy pitching staff with a back end filled with uncertainty and promise. With Joba in our pen, both teams have a solid 8-9, but the questions seep in about the bridge before then. Right now, our teams are very similar. Hence, injury, ineffectiveness and fulfilment of promise will decide who takes the east.