Derrek Lee's 07 sucked?
.317/.400/.513 all well above Youk's numbers. Lee had more homers, doubles, runs etc. You love numbers jayhawk, but this one isnt even close
Helton has been better over his whole career and once again had a higher BA, OBP and SLG last yr. Also, Helton is equal to Youkilis in defense. Youk's strength, the walks, well Helton had nearly 50% more.
As for Morneau, 65HR and 241 RBIs over 2 yrs is the type of production I expect from a first baseman. Youkilis has him on the walks (not by much) and the average. But Morneau slugs better. Then again, if you count the past 2 yrs (exactly the amt of time Youkilis has been a regular), Morneau is better, much better.
You are really going to try to argue Berkman being worse than Youkilis? Really? Mr. Numbers is actually going to try and defend that? Stupidity. Berkman's down yr was better that Youks best yr.
Konerko's decline phase last yr was better than Youkilis' season once again. Higher OPS with more power, similar walks, but less hits.