To spark some conversation, I figured I would do some rankings for teams thus far.
Top 3 Rotations:
1. CrespoBlows: Easy choice here. He has the best pitcher in the game, and then a fantastic staff behind him. King Felix has kind of been forgotten after the initial hype, but he's still only 23 and I expect him to be great. Lester has struggled this year, and his 2008 may even be his ceiling, but he's a solid middle of the rotation starter, with a higher potential. Kazmir, like Lester, has sucked this year. He has career worsts in walk, hit, K and HR rates. Still, this is an extreme for him and we've seen what he can do. Porcello is going to be amazing.
2. DipreG: Lincecum and Price should be one of the best 1-2 combos in this league, probably second behind Santana-Hernandez. I don't think I need to say much more about them. Verlander struggled last year but is off to a great start this year, leading the AL in strikeouts, and boasting a 1.10 WHIP. He should be a solid #2 for most teams, and is a 3 on this team. Scott Baker is a nice piece in the 4 slot. He had an excellent (albeit not full) season last year and is just entering his prime. The 5 slot is still up in the air here.
3. Dojji: I was torn on this last spot in my rankings between a bunch of staffs. Greinke makes this staff, however. Obviously he's having a remarkable 2009 so far, and he has the stuff to continue it. The question for him is the composure, and it seems that he's worked that out. Shields is another great starter, and though he's having a slight down year so far, I think he's a pretty good bet for a mid-3 ERA with a 1.1-1.2 WHIP. The rest of the rotation is more iffy for me, which is why I teetered with some other teams. Zambrano doesn't thrill me with his control (led the NL in walks in 2006 and 2007), but he's worked around it to be a fairly consistent (apologies to Joe Morgan) pitcher, and a good value in the 3 slot. Bush is a very interesting pitcher. If you look at his stats the past three years they don't jump out--ERAs of 5.12, 4.18 and 3.92 from 07-09. His WHIPs are more impressive, and I think he's a solid middle of the rotation guy.
I'll do lineups when teams are a little closer to having a full 9.