Ahhhh some baseball talk, let's break this down. . .
Schill, lets get one thing established right up front, you're not comparing playing baseball in South Florida with playing in Boston are you?
That clarification aside, its all well and good what Jack McKeon said about them but Jack McKeon ain't playing third or short for us and Kevin Millar was a "proven leader" as well.
The fact of the matter is this re: Lowell and Gonzalez
1. Alex Gonzalez has never hit over .265 in any of his 8 Major League seasons.
2. Alex Gonzalez is a career .240 hitter
3. His OBP is dreadful (.291)
4. His SP is dreadful (.391)
5. By default, I guess that makes his OPS dreadful as well.
What reason, outside of blind faith, makes you think he'll turn that around this year?
More on Alex. . .
He has no speed (23 SB's in 8 years) and he's been caught 17 times for a % of 58%
This guy is Pokey Reese with less defensive ability.
Mike Lowell:
Hit 27 HR's in 500 AB's in 2004
Hit 8 HR's in 500 AB's in 2005
Why the drop off?
One thing to consider here is what changed in the landscape of MLB between the two years?
Anyone?
Anyone?
The answer is the steroid thing broke.
I'm not saying Lowell was on the juice, but the dramatic drop off in:
a. average
b. homers
c. slugging
has to be explained somehow, no?
He only missed 12 games so something is going on.
Same question about Lowell that I had about Gonzalez:
What reason, outside of blind faith, makes you think he'll turn that around this year?
Note also that both these guys have played their entire careers in South Florida (except Lowell, I think, came up w/ the Yanks) And South Florida is not Boston.
I'm sorry where did I do that?
I'm not being hard on Youkilis
He is what he is
And what he is, is a guy with 250 ML AB's, who's never gone thru the rigors of a ML season before and with the exception of a run of games in 2004 has never shown the ability to hit for power which is something "most teams" look for from their starting first basemen. I don't hate Kevin Youkilis. No one wants the kid to thrive more than I do but the fact of the matter is he has done nothing to this point in his career to prove to me he's a servicable everyday first basemen and the consensus that this kid is gonna ride into town like The Man With No Name in High Plains Drifter and save the day is nothing more than wishful thinking.
I'll defer to your expertise on Mark Loretta