I think it's fair to question what's going on with Ortiz because I remember last year at about this time, the top story on Sunday Night Baseball's Red Sox vs. Yankees game was David Ortiz hitting .071. He was a dominant offensive power in '03, '04, '05, and '06, but his home runs have gone down since, and his average dropped last year.
What would be the wost-case scenario with him? I mean, he ended last year with 23 home runs, which was decent. If he ended this year with similar numbers in home runs, plus batting avg, OBP, etc. do you officially move him out of the 3-hole and bat him 5th, 6th?