This team has the potential to be very dangerous in the post season. The problem is that they probably will not make it to the post season due to injuries and other reasons. Yes, I said other reasons.
The failure of this team is not due entirely to injuries. Sure they are a major factor-- by themselves they are probably a deciding factor. In the end, we will probably miss the playoffs by a small handful of games. Had it not been for the injuries, they certainly would have closed the gap. Despite the injuries, I think this team still could have made the playoffs, but other mistakes were made. Our third base coach easily cost this team 3-4 victories with his terrible decision making. A third base coach should never have such a negative impact on a team. If we miss the playoffs by 3 or 4 games, Bogar shares the blame and that is sad. There were a number of games early in the season that were handed to inferior opposing teams due to bad defense, bone headed plays and general sloppy play. Good teams let bad teams give away games, not the other way around. Sloppy, fundamentally unsound play against inferior opponents leads to a conclusion that the 2010 Sox are not a very good team. They are a very talented team, but not a very good team. There is a difference. Their record against the weakest teams bears this out. Injuries is not an excuse for that. They have themselves to blame for the poor performance against those teams. If they had taken care of business against those teams, they would have 3 or 4 more wins.
The FO doesn't escape responsibility either. They did virtually nothing to build a bullpen during the season even though the need for a left handed pitcher was obvious in April. The bullpen cost us 3 or 4 games more than it should have.
As the string of long term devastating occurred, they did nothing helpful to reinforce the team. We have seen weeks and months of AAAA players, who have performed admirably, but we depended too much on them. The acquisition of Patterson was a joke. Expecting Cash to be the starting catcher for weeks after Tek and VMart went down was also a very poor decision. They acted much too slowly to get Salty or someone else to step in. We went for a good couple of weeks rolling out lineups with 4 or more substandard ML hitters. Yes, blame the injuries. The FO could not have replaced everyone, but one more good bat might have changed the outcome of a couple or 3 of those games. That 2 week tailspin was devastating to the team's prospects. Yes, the FO gets a share of blame too. Injuries were the major reason, but they are part of the game and they do not excuse everything else.
All that being said, if this team gets hot and gets a few breaks, they will make it to the post season, and none of this will matter. We need Pedroia to come out of the gates smoking next week. That could be the jump start we need.