I brought up Broxton, because he too is a great closer that has had some real stinkers this season. People get so overboard reactionary when Papelbon has a bad game. They all have some stinkers (maybe with the exception of Rivera). You say that you are not willing to pay Paps $10 per year, but for that same $10 million can the FO improve the team in other areas that will more than make up for the tremendous loss in the bullpen from letting him go. That is the value decision that the FO will make. They are not going to decide not to pay Papelbon because he is running his mouth and they have Bard. If Papelbon brings more value to the team at $10 million than they can find on the market at other positions for that $10 million, then the sound business judgment would be to keep him.