From everything that has been said about Iglesias, his fielding prowess is off the charts. No one disagrees with that. The question isn't whether he is in Ozzie Smith's class and no one has said that to my knowledge. Ozzie is the best fielding shortstop of all time in my opinion and Iggy doesn't need that kind of pressure handed to him. My argument is his bat, or lack of it, his poor plate discipline, his total
absence of power and his wasted speed where he cannot use it to steal bases.
As Palodios said, though, IF six or seven of our hitters are hitting it is possible we could carry such a weak bat for the defense he gives us, but, again, we better be ready to pinch hit for him in the late innings of a close game. However, if we have some of our batters imitating Crawford, Youkilis and Drew, circa 2011, no way we can carry such a weak bat.