I have done all I can to make adjustments for this "original" Super Bowl Grid and the Bonus Grid contests. They are now both closed. But some adjustments were made. The carryover/ bonus square has been eliminated. It is now filled by me ( square 8 & 6 ). This means there be a distinct winner for each prize. In addition, the rest of the 36 members of this board will get a square in the " Bonus Super Bowl Grid " see : http://www.talksox.com/forum/showthread.php?p=114220#post114220
We ended up with 53 different members in the grids. Which I think is great. The breakout is :
First 25 Entries : Get four squares ( 3 in Original & 1 in the Bonus grid, I'm the exception, I have 4 in the original & none in the Bonus ). Thus they're entered in two grids with almost twice the prizes.
The next 12 Entries : get 3 squares ( 2 in Original & 1 in the Bonus grid ). Thus they're entered in two grids with almost twice the prizes.That said, here is the revised grid ( the only thing that has changed is I, SFoC now has the former extra square) :
The next 16 Entries : get 4 squares all in the Bonus grid.
If you look at scenarios:
--One, the original grid was ended, 12 members would have been eliminated, and the 25 would get 4 squares with about half the prizes. Or what I did, and had all were included with 3 squares for the 25, 2 squares for the 12 ( half the prizes now ). Then create a second Grid ( the Bonus ). Unfortunately, these members faced a strong chance of not reaching the required 20, as this grid was at 16. Under the rules this grid would have been cancelled.
--Two, I let the original contest run and the same amount of members entered ( 53 ). This would mean 3 members eliminated and the other 50 would have 2 squares and half the prizes.
So I think its obvious that the current solution ( although not perfect ) is the most equitable.
Here is the adjusted grid :