Scutaro is a career 92 OPS+ hitter to Gonzalez's 80, with most of that edge coming in the more important OBP component of the stat. Yeah, Gonzalez is better with the glove, but his offense is, historically, much weaker. If you told me that he'd have 10 HR and be hitting at 129 OPS+ in mid-May, I'd have signed up for that, but I'd also have called you crazy if you made that prediction based on his history.