The Giants are a tough call going into the season. The NFC East is going to be tough this year, even for the Cowboys, who I feel are certainly the best but not so good to walk away with it. Philly got better where they were weakest, defense. The Redskins, my team, got better on both sides of the ball. I don't think the Giants improved anywhere, although I do see how improvement could come from individuals, like Manning.
For the 'Skins it's essentially the same defense with the addition of Jason Taylor and the continuing emergence of Rocky McIntosh, who I think is on the way to being a star. One of their big weaknesses last year was a lack of edge pressure. Taylor should change that, both with his ability to create pressure, and with his ability to draw extra attention. Andre Carter, the lone rush threat, managed 10 sacks while drawing all the attention last year. It will be interesting to see what he can do if he's not the focus of the opposing OC. Griffin and Montgomery, backed by Fletcher at MLB, are solid up the middle. They rated 3 in YPC against. The secondary was OK last year, but I think they'd didn't realize their potential due to their 28th ranking in percentage of pass plays that go for negative yards, and they be better in terms of personnel with Carlos Rogers playing the whole year and not going on the IR (hopefully).
The offense addressed it's 2 main needs, and will get better by return from injury. They lost RT Jansen in week 1 last year. He'll improve the talent makeup of the line this year, who is largely unchanged from last year. They ran the ball well with Portis and Betts last year, but not great. I think this was Gibbs, and replacing him was need #1. He was so predictable it was almost funny. Zorn is a WC offense guy, so while they won't run as much, it should improve in terms of how effectively they run. Need #2 was a big target WR. They drafted 2 on the first day. WR is probably 2nd to RB in terms of being able to contribute immediately. So Thomas and Kelly should be able to start getting reps and opening the field for the corps of slot-type receivers they appear to have cornered the market on, lead by Santana Moss.
This is a big year for Campbell. No, I'm not saying I think he has a big year, although he could, but that it is an important one. He played reasonably well in Gibbs' system last year, but Gibbs' system does not match his talents. Look at the best statistical seasons by Gibbs' QBs and you'll notice a common trend. They could all throw a beautiful long ball, like Mark Rypien. Gibbs was from the pound it, pound it, pound it, chuck it school of thought in terms of strategy. Campbell's biggest weakness, IMO, is his deep ball. He's got the arm, it's just not very accurate. He's much better suited to hit the short to mid timing routes that the WC offense is predicated upon, something that Mark Rypien was horrible at. Campbell will have a system that fits him better this year, but he needs to do something with it. They drafted Colt Brennan in this year's draft, and the kid is drawing some attention in the preseason, albeit against guys just trying to make the roster. Still if he keeps this up, there will be pressure to give him a look if Campbell should falter.