I'm breaking out a thread from the Sox "Catcher and SS situations" thread because that one complains about the situation rather than discussing it... and each situation probably deserves its own thread (with the SS situation thread beginning and ending with Jed Lowrie).
My question/thought is, how are the Sox ever going to replace Tek? Even Victor Martinez struggled managing the pitching staff. Tek calls the pitches and the pitchers throw them, while Salty (and seemingly everyone else) calls the pitches and hopes it is the pitch the pitcher wants to throw. You don't see people shaking off Tek nearly as often as the other catchers, and he often pauses before flashing his sign as if he--not the pitcher--is the one with the ultimate call. Pitchers trust that if he's thought about it and calls it, that's the pitch to throw.
I'm not sure that skill is a matter of just training with Varitek or learning from what he does. He may just have a natural skill and/or years of experience for reading hitters, studying them, and making good decisions in the moment given that particular pitcher's stuff.
I think pitchers do a MUCH better job when they leave the pitch calling to the catchers and just throw what they're told to throw. Watching Beckett or Lackey or Dice-K struggle with which sign the catcher puts down is frustrating to say the least. Watching the Angels, I notice that Mike Scioscia calls a lot of the pitches from the bench. Is that ultimately going to be the answer, to have Tek calling pitches from the bench after he retires? He's clearly got leadership written all over him and it would be natural for him to be on a bench somewhere helping pitchers and catchers perfect their craft.
I just worry about such a veteran and experienced pitching staff with any catcher who doesn't command the respect that Tek does behind the plate. Perhaps catcher isn't the position to develop internally, unless you get one of the truly elite guys (Posey, Mauer, etc.,) to develop from within. I think Salty deserves more opportunity and think he'll be a viable option, but it could take him 5+ years to get the clout that a veteran like Tek has and maybe the Sox staff just need that veteran to feel comfortable with their catcher...
It seems to make a difference for some of these pitchers.