Re: dumpster diving:
Frankly, I would much rather a team be good at drafting or trading or developing its drafted players or choosing which FA to let go than at dumpster diving.
Ripping on them because they can't pull diamonds out of piles of horseshit with regularity seems a bit silly.
Why dive into a dumpster for a 35 year old d-bag when you can give a shot to a home-grown player who you hope will become part of the rotation/lineup for a longer period. That's kind of been their philosophy. Yes, they tried with guys like Wade Miller, John Smoltz, Bartolo Colon (who many cite as an example of success with the Yankees, right?), Jeremy Hermeda, yada yada
These 11 players cost less than the average "dumpster dives" when they first started contributing to the team and some of them have reached superstar status:
Papelbon
Lester
Pedroia
Ellsbury
Lowrie
Delcarman
Buchholz
Bard
Reddick
Lavarnway
Doubront