My biggest surprises:
Carp: Batting .300 in limited playing time, comes onto the field when asked to step in and usually makes some sort of impact. Always great to have a backup guy who doesn't mind being a backup guy and plays his hardest when he's in the lineup. Even better when his hardest is actually good.
Ortiz: The man is getting old. He's the only player left from the '04 team, and that was almost a decade ago. I thought he'd run out of steam a couple years after that, but here we are, ten years later. I've gone through three or four girlfriends, approximately 3650 toothbrushes, four cars, and almost certainly enough cigarettes to asphyxiate a small city, and David Ortiz is still hitting harder than the hour after the Super Bowl party at Chris Brown's house. Gotta love Ortiz.
Nava: What can I say? I thought he'd be, at best, a mildly serviceable backup. Instead he's one of the best outfielders around. From the very first pitch he saw this kid has played his pale, skinny guts out and proven to the Sox, their fans, and I bet at least one high school girlfriend that giving up on Daniel Nava too early just makes you look like the guy who thought computers were a passing fad.
Lackey: After one teeth-grinding year of pitching and one year of not pitching at all, John Lackey is the ace of the staff right now while Buchholz is out. He's really taken hold of the reins and horse joke horse joke horse joke.
Tazawa and Uehara: The only reason I haven't nicknamed these two incredible guys Hiroshima and Nagasaki is because I am barely clinging to a shred of human dignity and morals and I'm not quite ready to let go of it, at least not until I can transfer my consciousness into an indestructible murder-robot body. These guys are awesome, and deserving of some double nickname that isn't racially, culturally, and morally insensitive.
Disappointments:
Hanrahan and Bailey- Hanrahan is injured, obviously, and as much as that sucks, it happens and there is no reason to complain about it. He could come back healthy one day and be the closer, so I'll reserve judgement. I am still disappointed at not having him, though. As for Bailey, I thought the bad stretch was just that, a bad stretch, but then it continued. I can't help but wonder if he's injured, collapsing that completely is very odd.
Napoli- I am disappointed with the Ks as well as the power outage of late. His last homerun came a while ago. I am pleased that he is working counts and making pitchers labor, but I am a little worried that his tendency to not make contact will doom him as the second half plays out. I hope not, though, and I am sure of one thing: Napoli is the kind of guy who can turn this around.
Brian Butterfield: Never thought I'd find myself missing Dale Sveum.
Drew: Eh. Every time he looks like he's about to go on a tear, he sputters back down to nothingness.