OK fine, a closed minded Sox fan knows more about my Yankees than me. If you don't watch the games you don't know. Posada doesn't do anything. His homeruns come in blowouts and his RBIs are padded by games where the hitters in front of him dominate mediocre pitchers like Travis Harper. But on the other hand, Flaherty the last few years has actually made a surprising difference in games he wiggles into. But I wouldn't know because you OBVIOUSLY have more knowledge on the Yankees than I do. Two games against the Sox come to mind. The John Flaherty double off Clement turned out to practically be the difference in the game.... and his walk-off single against Leskanic on July 1st of last year, those are two legitimate hits that I can't think of comparisons for Jorge, he just isn't a clutch hitter whatsoever. Flaherty is a superior defensive player, but he played once a week if he was lucky earlier on in the season, but now that he is getting consistent playing time he actually can work on his stroke. But he is still just a back-up, but if you don't just live in stats you would've have witnessed that he has been the difference in games, through plays at the plate, clutch hits, sac bunts, or just the way he calls the game.
Plus I know I am not the only Yankee fan who thinks this. I would feel more comfortable when John Flaherty starts, I feel like we have much more of a chance to win.