I can imagine a person of any age not able to catch a fly ball. I know you're referring to Duran and the ball he couldn't see and he didn't hustle after. So, I agree, all SOX fans should judge Duran's present and future on that one play. Of course, if Duran starts putting wood to the ball the like he did last night, I'm pretty sure that will all be forgotten. Because if a player can hit, all of a sudden his defense is less important. Two perfect examples would be Bogey and Jeter.