I too am for getting a big bat and possibly also improving by getting a better player to replace someone that is good but not very good. I do think we have to maintain a balance up and down the lineup and not put all of the emphasis on one player. So who do we part company with and who do we keep as a core group? In my view, we would be well to keep our outfield together for its speed, defensive ability and still potential to improve offensively. As far as catcher is concerned, I am not wowed by either of our guys but think they do a serviceable job for us. That leaves the infield and DH as places where we could get that big bat and also probably also make an additional change to shore up our positions. We really need to do that on a value basis and we shouldn't pay any of these guys over their real value in either salary or time commitment, realizing BB is a competitive business and we still need to pay competitive amounts.
I do think we should keep Devers and either play him at 3rd or move him to first depending what is best for the club. I also think we have Pedey under contract and need Nunez to come back as a super sub if we can make that happen. Beyond that I see opportunities with first base, DH and shortstop. I don't recommend giving away the store in prospects to get a better bat and anyone we sign as a free agent or trade for needs to be able to hold down a position first and be a DH second. Bogey is still a young player and has more value just due to the years left in his career. Based on his level of play, I would be satisfied if we could either trade him and work to get a significantly better player or stand pat. Moreland has been pretty good for us but is the obvious choice to be replaced by a player with a superior bat and decent defense. Good luck finding that player. I too would think trading Hanley away, even if we had to eat some of the contract, would be in our interest. We should be able to replace him and get equally good numbers at a far better value, but who would want him?
Our utility players would include Nunez but we should be looking for a Young, Holt replacement. We have Lin, Hernandez, Swihart and Travis available and still others may emerge in the minors. Chavis may come along and be available next season. I look for speed, defensive ability, flexability in positions played and at least a contributor offensively.
Pitching is a separate story and I won't comment on that here.