I like stats too. I always have. In fact, someplace in my ex-wife's house are copies of the first 10 or so years of Bill James' Baseball Abstracts. Much of what I know and believe about baseball I learned from Bill James. I even used some of his beliefs when I was coaching, with quite a lot of success, to the point where I was questioned about what I was doing even when it was successful.
However, IMHO somewhere along the line "we" became so obsessed with statistics that some of us can no longer see the forest for the trees. That's why I continue to say that there's room for both the statistics and the intangibles in our beliefs.