The best manager in baseball is Joe Maddon. Second is the Giants manager. I think these 2 would do better than Farrell. I'm not sure about anyone else. I also really like the young Dave Roberts ( ex sock), who helped get us in the World Series in '04. One characteristic of a great manager is knowing how to use your players and how to motivate them. I see this with Joe but not so much with John this year. John has so much talent on the team this year that its hard to know who to use when. Having a player like Hanley can be a challenge for any manager (so much raw talent but he is a bit of an under-achiever). He has single handedly won some games for us but also single-handedly lost us a few. It's Papi's last year, he's still a great fielder and should be playing in the NL games vs. RH pitchers. This is the kind of problem I have with Farrell. We still might get to the big show but right now I'm a little worried about John.
Maybe Dombrowski's putting too much pressure on him. It's gotta be fun too. Magic=fun and The most magic I have seen this year has come from Peedie's glove, not from walk-offs, and not from brilliant managerial moves.