I get that Vaz is loved by the pitching staff. He's good, probably phenomenal at that position and it's almost easy to see. But there is a line where his bat has to perform. And there is a line where he has to come back from a major surgery and perform for a year or years to come. We don't know that yet. And the set back last year really hurt us knowing what we have. Maybe patience is the best practice here. I'm agreeing with you that Swihart can get a very good return in a trade. I think it could be even better with some seasoning with him at the position. For all we know he could have been shopped before V went down and didn't yield a return that was worth it. Personally..... I wouldn't trade for a promising catcher.
His stock went up in the offense category last year. The guy hit over 300 the second half and he proved himself. He just needs work on defense, which he never had.
I think comparing him to Vazquez is a problem. One of them are trade chips and it doesn't matter how much better one is. We win if they are both good players. The one that looks a bit behind gets delt. The other thing is which one is more important to the current pitching staff. We have Vasquez trying to rescue a bunch of struggling pitchers. If we had a staff we were confident in, then maybe Swihart and his not so good behind the plate ability would be ok with him racking 300 at the plate.
Yes, we may have missed the boat. But I think we saw some greatness out of a AA player than needs reps.