Well I surely don't know if Lester is washed up at this point. But, if I was giving him advice I would tell him that if he is goin' out, he is going out with a whimper when he should at least go out with a bang. He is better than this. He is a better pitcher than he is showing at this point.
Every time he goes out and attacks the zone, attacks hitters, at least as much as he seems willing to these days, he has a pretty good outing. Every time he goes out and dicks around, he is just terrible. Today he did nothing to earn hitters respect. There was no place in the strike zone and no pitch that he could throw in the strike zone with impunity. D-back hitters owned the plate against him today. Any starting pitcher will tell you that you can't pitch successfully that way. Pretty tough to pitch bent over a table with your pants down around your ankles. If this less than aggressive posture was working for him I would say go for it Jon. But it doesn't work. The D-backs got something like eleven hits off of him. They were able to reach all the way across the plate with impunity and even pull the ball if they wanted to. They were as comfortable as if they were taking BP.
I don't know what he is afraid of cause it can't be worse for him than when he pitches like this. He has his worst outings pitching this way.
One thing for certain, Peavy will not pitch like that. He may not win but he sure as hell won't be walking off the mound pulling his pants back up along the way.