To answer the original question, I prefer Gomes. The energy he brings to the team is nothing but positive. Over the last few months, I haven't been all that impressed with Nava. Besides the hit in game 1, he's done virtually nothing at the plate in the ALCS, or even the playoffs tbh. Yes, I know the whole offense is struggling, but I feel much better about our chances with Gomes in the lineup. He's dangerous as a power hitter, and that aspect alone is enough for me.