I'm not saying he wasn't fun to watch as a player, but in my opinion the guy was kind of a douchebag. Would I like to see him in our lineup again, yeah if you duct tape his mouth.
All the stuff he said in 2008 about the Red Sox not deserving him really put him on my s*** list. As a hitter he's great, but as a person he pisses me off. I loved him right up until 2008.
Plus sue me for saying this but I think Jason Bay is a much better player than Manny Ramirez. When we made that trade I saw it as an upgrade. My reasoning was that Manny could hit, and that was about it. Bay could hit for power, he could play the field, he wasn't a loudmouth and a distraction, and he hustled. I can only say one of those things for Manny.
Sure he was on 2 World Series teams and contributed a lot to the Sox in his 7 or so years with the team but I think I have a legitimate reason to dislike him.