I'm not saying he's a great game caller right now, but I think with experience both with our pitching staff and in the league, along with mentoring from Varitek, he could become a great game caller. The reason his CERA is high this year is because he's got no idea what these pitchers want to throw. Pitchers thrive on rhythm, which is why Tek has such a low CERA, he's always on the same page with the pitchers, and that's because he's worked so long with the pitchers and against the league. He knows what pitch to call, how to set up the hitters, the hitters weaknesses, etc. That's all stuff that doesn't just come overnight.
I'm not trying to defend Salty to the point where I'm hard headed about making a change. I just know that there are really not many options left. I mean you think Doumit, well he's a catcher in the NL who has never caught in the AL, doesn't know the AL East, doesn't know our pitchers, and he has a career 4.92 CERA in the NL East. Salty has a career 4.69 CERA, so is it really an upgrade, especially since the biggest concern with Salty is his defense? Salty can hit, that will come around, he may not be a 20 HR, .280 hitter, but he'll be a 12-14 HR, .260 hitter, which is fine in this line up.
All I'm saying is let him get acclimated to the pitching staff before we replace him. You wouldn't dump a girl because cooked you something that you didn't like on the 2nd date, let Salty get to know these pitchers and then we can make judgements.